Joe sends details of Allisons visions to different law enforcement establishments with the hope of proving that Allisons visions are nonsense. Surprisingly to Joe, there ends up being many similarities between a dream of Allisons and a homicide case from Texas. Allison is called to work on the case and butts heads with Captain Kenneth Push, who is doubtful of her psychic abilities. Captain Push comes to respect Allison and her abilities by the end of the investigation.

Allison finally receives a call from D.A. Devalos who asks her to help him select a jury who will give the death penalty to a murder-rapist. Allison is confident that her powers will help, but later suspects that she has put the wrong man on death row.

D.A. Devalos introduces Allison to his friend Detective Lee Scanlon, whom he believes she might be able to help. Allison discovers that Scanlon refuses to believe that the death of his sister and her husband is a murder-suicide and that he has been trying to find out who really murdered them for two years. This causes her to believe previously dismissed dreams she's been having of a husband and wife's murder-suicide are true. Scanlon reacts with skepticism and anger when he is told Allison has psychic abilities. Though when her theories start to come true, he realizes that her abilities may be legitimate and that with her help, he may be able to stop the killer before he murders anyone else.

Allison tries to convince D.A. Devalos that they're looking for the wrong person when she overhears a murder witness giving untrue information to a police sketch artist. She has a recurring dream of being chased through an airport by a wolf, which holds the answer to saving her when she is face to face with the real killer. Meanwhile, Bridgette makes a new friend who no one else seems to be able to see, which means that Allison may not be the only one in the family who sees the dead.

Allison is very upset that her psychic abilities cannot tell her anything about Joe's health when he undergoes a medical procedure. She asks Catherine, a psychic she met not too long ago, for help. Catherine tells her that Joe is in good health, but warns her that she'll be faced with a crisis involving a third person. Allison starts to suspect that Joe is having an affair when she has a vision of him with someone she doesn't know. Allison is also in another tough situation and must decide if she should lie about her psychic abilities on the stand at a murder trial. Catherine comes to her aid and offers her a unique solution to this problem.

Allison is convinced that a good samaritan is actually a serial killer she's been seeing in her dreams when he shows up at D.A. Devalos's office with information about a burglary. She tracks down a victim who ends up still being alive. Allison's obsession with the suspected killer makes Joe wonder if she is possibly pregnant again.

Allison finds the body of a young woman in a ravine after having dreams about the woman killing herself by jumping off a cliff. Larry Watt, the defense attorney who previously threatened to expose Allison's abilities in court, is revealed to be the father of Greg, the dead woman's boyfriend, complicating the crime. Physical evidence points towards Larry being involved in the woman's death, but Allison believes that the victim is trying to show her the truth. Meanwhile, Joe becomes concerned about his colleague's health after Allison tells him about a premonition she had about the colleague.

Allison has an emotionally draining dream of her brother Michael being killed in Afghanistan while serving there for the U.S. Army. Allison is also given an arson case in which a victim isn't revealing all she knows, causing her added stress to her life.

Allison and Joe ask D.A. Devalos and Detective Scanlon for help when Ariel dreams of a girl who looks exactly like her who is being held prisoner by an ogre in a far away castle. Ariel, taking after her mother, is determined to figure out the true meaning of her dream.

D.A. Devalos asks for Allison's help with a 14 year-old confessed murder. Meanwhile, Allison has a recurring dream of two young boys racing a train. In her dream, the boys are separated when only one gets across the track. Allison is led to Professor Leonard Cardwell, who is an expert when it comes to communication with the afterlife.

Allison starts watching re-runs of a popular 1960's sitcom, I Married a Mind Reader while she is home with a bad cold. The sitcom stared real-life husband and wife Abigail Marsh and Henry Stoller, and was cancelled after Stoller was convicted of murdering his wife. Allison has dreams about the show and suspects that something isn't right concerning Marsh's murder. She decides to investigate on her own to see what she can find out about Abigail Marsh's murder.

Allison's abilities are put to the test when she sees the execution of a convicted drug lord whose girlfriend is murdered on the night of his death. Allison also discovers the tragic truth about the mother of Ariel's best friend.

Allison must decide if she should help investigators build a case against a jerky airline pilot who is suspected of killing his wife. Allison had a dream where hundreds of people were killed in a plane crash when the man went to jail and is put into a moral dilemma - should she let a guilty man go free or put him in jail at the cost of hundreds of innocent lives?

Allison is put in a tough spot when a 10 year-old case is reopened. She has information that proves the innocence of a convicted murderer and which may be able to set him free. Allison's situation gets worse when she thinks that someone she knows and trusts was possibly involved in the framing of the murderer. Meanwhile, Joe's mother comes to visit him.

Allison is confronted with the evil spirit of a psychotic doctor who is responsible for the murder of 14 young girls, and has difficulties in stopping him from taking another victim. Meanwhile, Ariel is accused of cheating by her math teacher and Joe has a tough time trying to prove her innocence.

In the first season finale, Captain Kenneth Push returns after Allison sees him in a vision at a murder scene and asks for his assistance in finding a serial killer. Allison and Captain Push rush to find the serial killer before he can claim another victim, and Captain Push decides that the only way he can help Allison is to put his life on the line.